John Leckie hears it first on a cassette demo, and the producer is sure on the spot: “It sounded instantly like a big track.” Everyone agrees. That is where the trouble starts.
Big means the whole band in the room, drums up, guitars stacked. Yorke says they wanted it to sound like Phil Spector. What comes back is bombast. Ed O’Brien remembers one full-band version sounding like “November Rain”, “so pompous and bombastic, just the worst.” They try again. It gets bigger, and somehow smaller.
So the song that sounded easiest on tape becomes the one Radiohead cannot catch. It finally comes on a bad day; Yorke’s own word for it is stronger. How the finished track actually came together is the part nobody would guess from hearing it.
Then there is the voice. Yorke spends long stretches up in falsetto, a register that can tip into syrup fast. Something he saw in 1994 showed him another way to use it. Listen to how little sits between him and the microphone. It is about as exposed as a singer gets.
The trees are fake. The voice is not.
The words came second. Melody first, lyric after, and on paper the lyric is a bleak little inventory: plastic, rubber, polystyrene, a former cosmetic surgeon, a woman worn down by all of it. Almost everyone hears it as Radiohead at their most earnest. What Yorke felt at the desk while he wrote it is a different story.
Now the business. Capitol picks it as the band’s first American single from The Bends, partly, says co-manager Chris Hufford, to put distance between Radiohead and “Creep”. The way out of a loud hit, they decide, is a slow acoustic song.
Keep an ear, too, on the moment the electric guitars arrive. There is a small story in exactly when they do.
Smash Hits gives it two out of five: “Mournfully slow and really unremarkable.” It peaks at No. 20 in the UK and never reaches the Hot 100. The tag sticks, the sad one, the song for lying on the floor, and it follows the track into places happy to mock exactly that. Rolling Stone later names it among the 500 greatest songs of all time. Thirty years on, in Madrid, it opens the encore.
Mournfully slow, fine. Unremarkable is the part that aged badly.
Pearls
0 of 5 surfaced
Surface any pearl, in any order, to hear what's really going on.
I
“Radiohead cut this as a band, then dressed it in strings.”
tap to surface
I
It was built backwards. On a day Yorke later called "a complete nightmare", he had a meltdown, everyone left the studio, and he played it alone on acoustic guitar. That solo performance became the foundation of the released track. Producer John Leckie: "The whole track dynamic was created from Thom's original performance." Then the band had to fit themselves around it. Yorke: "it took bloody months to get everything else on top of it to sound natural."
tap to re-read
II
“That soft, high Thom Yorke voice is simply how he sang.”
tap to surface
II
Not at first. Yorke had kept the soft, high part of his voice in reserve until, in London in 1994, he watched Jeff Buckley play a solo show. Producer John Leckie put the shift plainly: "It made [Thom] realize you could sing in a falsetto without sounding dripping." The fragile upper voice carrying this song is the one he had been holding back.
tap to re-read
III
“Fake Plastic Trees is Radiohead's earnest lament about a fake, consumer world.”
tap to surface
III
Yorke started out laughing at it. The melody came first, and when the words followed he said he "wrote those words and laughed. I thought they were really funny, especially that bit about polystyrene." Later he called the song "the product of a joke that wasn't really a joke, a very lonely, drunken evening and, well, a breakdown of sorts." The lament you hear began as a punchline that stopped being funny.
tap to re-read
IV
“Radiohead are perfectionists; mistakes don't survive onto their records.”
tap to surface
IV
This one survived on purpose. Yorke told Q in 1997: "Paul [Kolderie] missed a cue, so the electric guitars don't come in at the right place. It was a mistake, but we kept it." A band this careful chose to leave a mixing slip right there in plain hearing. Wait for the electric guitars next time. They arrive where nobody planned them.
tap to re-read
V
“Clueless handed Radiohead a big 1995 Hollywood moment.”
tap to surface
V
The moment was a punchline. Clueless plays the song, in its acoustic version, in a scene where Cher dismisses it as whiny, maudlin college-radio music. Music supervisor Karyn Rachtman later said: "I looked at them as 'the whiny band'... They were fine with it." Yorke, in 2000, remembered it differently: "No, I had a problem with that... I was not into it at the time, because the music means a lot to me."
